Guest Review: If Anne Rice and Geraldine Brooks had a novel baby, Octavia Butler’s Fledgling would be it

By A. Heishman

Let me explain.

I am fortunate enough to work at a high school where the librarian is an amazing resource for little known gems.  So when I requested “junk reading that a isn’t about a princess and isn’t about a long lost magical item,” Fledging emerged from the stacks.  As a science fiction teacher, I love Octavia Butler and her wonderful brand of dystopia.  I had expected a bit of the same in Fledgling, her only vampire novel.

That’s right. Vampire novel.  Octavia Butler.

Fledging was Butler’s last novel and, if I’m being honest, her worst one. However, in the genius that was the Parable series, a vampire novel doesn’t really stand a chance.  Arguably, Fledging is an exercise in writer’s block; Butler struggled with the curse for years before her unexpected death.  I can completely comprehend Fledgling as a writing exercise or perhaps a way to re-invigorate her writing.  If looking to read Fledging in admiration of Butler . . . just don’t.

That doesn’t mean it isn’t enjoyable.  Fledging is an English teacher’s “junk reading” dream: it’s better writing than most, easy enough to forget the inner literary critic, and a compelling story.  As a vampire genre fan, Fledging is revolutionary re-do of the genre.  I gave up the Anita Blake series for lack of the same reason I love this novel: instead of focusing on the sexual nature and compulsion of vampires in popular culture, Butler builds the cultural world of the Ina (vampires) as a stand-alone civilization beyond the history of humanity.  There is sex but those episodes act more like cut-away scenes, unlike Anne Rice’s multiple page dedication to the romantic, lusty, or even aggressive sexual lives of humans and their vampires (or vampires and their humans).  Fledging is almost a coming of age story: Shori, a 53 year old vampire, awakes from the complete devastation and massacre of her family with amnesia.  Without any recollection of the conditions of her predicament, she must learn all over again the “Ina” (vampire) way, her own family history obliterated at the start of the novel. She searches and finds other Ina families in hopes of learning.  This would be fine were Shori not an exercise in genetic modification.

It’s still Octavia Butler, after all.

Unlike other vampires, Shori can walk during the day. This is how the lens shifts from a sexy tale about blood-thirsty predators to radically different species living symbiotically with humans all while developing their own culture, complete with genetic modification mastery.  No comparisons should be made to the movie Blade; this is not a story about the morality of vampires but rather the delicate way Shori navigates learning about Ina culture all while viewed as complete outsider to that inheritance.  Any serious attempt at literary analysis would easily find reason to see allegory or ties to the “other” in literature. However, the beauty of this novel is how easy it is to forget that literary critic in my head.  Instead, I reveled in the slow surprises and the depth at which Butler imagined Ina culture.

It’s not a good book but it’s a good read.  Just be warned: she died before any sequel surfaced as more than just precursory notes.  Who knows—maybe that might be good motivation for some very bad good fan fiction.


A. Heishman is an official Friend of the Blog (FoB) and a literature teacher and lover of science fiction.  To avoid grading, she plays video games, keeps house for three cats, and occasionally reviews books.  Her teaching blog is What’s Not on the Syllabus.

Interested in writing a guest review for Every Day Should Be Tuesday?  You can reach me to pitch a review at everydayshouldbetuesday at

About H.P.

Blogs on books at Every Day Should Be Tuesday (speculative fiction) and Hillbilly Highways (country noir and nonfiction).
This entry was posted in Book Reviews, Horror, Science Fiction and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Guest Review: If Anne Rice and Geraldine Brooks had a novel baby, Octavia Butler’s Fledgling would be it

  1. Pingback: A Book Review! | What's Not on the Syllabus

  2. Donnalee says:

    Hmm, I didn’t know about this book although I know of her as an author. The multicultural aspect of it, which probably also contains ptsd at loss of life and previous culture, might make it of interest to me. Thanks–this is an intelligently-written review.

    Liked by 2 people

  3. Bookstooge says:

    HP, I think Donnalee is talking some serious smack about you! That last phrase, oh, it cuts with its implications

    On a serious note, how do you handle guest posts? I’m interested in the gory details if you don’t mind.

    Liked by 2 people

    • H.P. says:

      A naif in the ways of Every Day Should Be Tuesday, were she merely to browse for half an hour, she would become hopelessly addicted to the dulcet tones of my prose, as your are good sir.

      The process is quite simple. You email me and say, “Hey H.P., how do you feel about laying out of work this Tuesday?” I check my schedule and confirm that I do, indeed, have more remunerative things to do than write book reviews. You send me a draft, asking if the tone is right. I patiently explain that my voice is matchless, any dreck will do. I surreptitiously edit your draft to reformat the ellipses and de-italicize the titles (of course, were you to use one space after a sentence instead of two, I would print your draft out so I could burn it). I then publish your guest review. If it proves successful I can always go back and edit out attribution after the fact.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. H.P. says:

    I’m pretty open. I wouldn’t want to run a review of a book I’ve already reviewed (unless it was a response) or, worse, a book I was about to review. But there are endless books I am unlikely to ever read and review. Tell them to shoot me an email with a pitch.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s