Spoiler Review of The Last Jedi (and Spoiler Comment Thread)

I posted a non-spoiler review yesterday, so you can get my initial, overall thoughts there.  But as I said in that review, to really talk about both what I liked and didn’t like in The Last Jedi, I’m going to have to go full spoiler.  Consider this fair warning.  Below the jump and the movie poster will be spoilers of all sorts.  Please do feel free to talk spoilers in the comment section as well.

At a macro level, there is some really bad storytelling here.  Perhaps more troubling than the direct impact on the plot is that those issues squander precious storytelling time.  The Last Jedi does a good job of breaking free of the very derivative nature of The Force Awakens (the biggest weakness to an otherwise very good movie) and advancing the story in new, interesting ways, with some good *pew* *pew* action in the process.  What it doesn’t do is build the world of Star Wars or even really expand the story.  It assuages my main fear after The Force Awakens, but it leaves a new main fear in its wake.  The trilogy ender has a lot more heavy lifting to do than Return of the Jedi did.

(The current Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer scores for The Last Jedi are 93% and 56% for critics and the audience, respectively.  Both of these are crazy.)

BEWARE! HERE BE SPOILERS!

The Last Jedi opens with the Resistance attempting to escape their base in advance of a First Order assault.  I saw someone online say they basically copied the battle of Hoth and I was worried it would be just that.  It is similar in that both are escapes, but they play out in very different ways.  The battle of Hoth was a ground battle, the battle here happens in space.

We get some nice flying by Poe as he works to disable the big cannons so the Resistance convoy can escape.  Even better is our introduction to Rose Tico, a new character.  With her sister dead, she has to climb from her gunner position in her bomber to release the bombs and destroy an imperial Dreadnought (an attack led by Poe against Leia’s orders, setting up my least favorite plotline in the movie).  [As Kyle points out in the comments, Rose wasn’t in bomber, only her sister Paige.]

I loved this scene with Rose, as well as her first scene with Finn.  Her last scene?  Not so much.  More on that in a bit.

Before I get into the stuff I didn’t like, and before I try to recap the entire movie, let’s cover the good.  It looks and sounds great.  It is a well put together movie, in that it doesn’t look like it was obviously cut up and restitched together in the editing room.  E.g., the visual cues that segue between scenes are clear.

I loved everything with Snoke (except maybe that we learn nothing about him).  Snoke manipulating Rey into traveling to Kylo Ren was great, but expected.  Andy Serkis does a wonderful job of chewing the scenery in the throne room scene.  But the best part was Kylo Ren seizing on Snoke’s gambit to kill Snoke.  This is a good example of how TLJ plays off of our expectations from The Empire Strikes Back and TFA by zigging when we expect them to zag.  Kylo Ren isn’t pulling a Vader, it is a power grab.  It is a gutsy storytelling call to setup a Big Bad and then kill them off in Act 2 of a trilogy, and I applaud it.

The other part I really, really loved was Luke joining the fray.  We knew it was going to happen.  But the moviemakers ratcheted up the tension by pushing it back and, more importantly, did it in an unexpected way.  Swooping in in his X-wing?  Nope, that is Rey and Chewie in the Falcon.  His appearance without explanation raises just enough doubt in the watcher’s mind to setup for the reveal.  The scene also cleverly calls back to Obi Wan Kenobi’s death without being derivative.  Of course, his actions wouldn’t have been necessary but for Rose…

I’m very glad that they (apparently) made Rey’s parents nobodies.  To have made them someone key from the franchise would have almost had to have undercut her story and character.  (I wrote a bit about that in a long post on Rey.)

Almost everything else I thought was good but not great.  Unfortunately, there were a few things that stuck in my craw.  Presented in order of ascending egregiousness.

The Canto Bight sequence was large unnecessary (actually it was completely unnecessary, but that is related to my least favorite element).  My friend pointed out that it is worldbuilding.  TLJ is somewhat curious in that we see virtually nothing of the larger universe.  We get the planet with the Resistance base, the planet with the Jedi temple, and the mineral planet at the end.  Other than Canto Bight, everything else takes place in space.  So you need some more worldbuilding, sure.  And you probably need a scene for pacing purposes.  And the moviemakers obviously felt they needed to show how evil the First Order is.  But it is a ham-handed attempt at any of that.  There is also a certain amount of misanthropy baked into feeling you need to show animals being hurt to show evil.

(Benicio Del Toro’s character is another example of playing off of our expectations, this time built on Lando’s arc in ESB.)

My second least favorite element was Rose stopping Finn from destroying the cannon.  Keep in mind what is going on.  That cannon is going to crack the Resistance’s defenses in an instant.  Without it, they are confident they can hold until help arrives.  The only reason the fighters—many of whom died—went out in the ski-ships was to disable the cannon.  Now, if Rose stops Finn because she realizes for some reason his death wouldn’t disable the cannon, fine.  Or, Rose could have done a terrible thing out of her love for Finn.  That would be tragic, but good storytelling.  Instead, they have Rose spout a nonsensical line at Finn about protecting the ones we love instead of killing the ones we hate.  Keep in mind, he was attacking an inanimate object, and the most likely result of Rose’s actions was the death of all of those people she loved back in the cave.  There would be a certain irony to Rose dying to prevent Finn’s heroic sacrifice in an utterly unheroic sacrifice of her own, but the moviemakers weren’t willing to kill her off (the best part of that scene is that they had me convinced they would kill off Finn, a positive side effect of killing off Snoke).  Luke’s heroic sacrifice would mean a lot more if you ignore that it would have been unnecessary but for Rose’s actions.

But my least favorite element by far was the entire arc of the admiral played by a badly miscast Laura Dern.  She assumes overall command after the top command circle is killed or incapacitated by an attack on the bridge of the flagship (due to one of those odd technological anachronisms of Star Wars—with even today’s tech there is no need for an exposed bridge with big windows).  She is immediately rude to Poe and shows her bias against him.  This is important.  If she knows anything about Poe, she knows he is their best pilot, extremely well regarded, and likes to go off-script.  At this time she apparently already has a plan to salvage what she can of the Resistance.

If she had just TOLD POE the plan, this entire plot thread would have never happened.  Finn and Rose would have had no reason to travel to Canto Bight.  Which means they would not have been captured, which means the First Order would not have learned of the transports.  So the admiral’s bad leadership resulted in the death of much of the remaining Resistance.  Perhaps most importantly, a lot of screen time could have been regained that could have been more fruitfully used.

Now, this isn’t necessarily bad storytelling.  The incompetent general who doesn’t listen to their subordinates is a pretty well-worn trope.  As is there redemption.  All you need is a little “what have I done?” horror from the admiral before she turns her ship on the First Order ships.  But neither the admiral nor the moviemakers show any recognition of the consequences of her actions.  Which does a lot to sully the otherwise awesome scene of her taking her ship into lightspeed to use it as a weapon (which just goes to show you that heroic sacrifice via kamikaze attack is ok so long as you aren’t too important a hero).  Of course with the ability to accelerate objects into lightspeed, one wonders why you would need to build even one Death Star.

The Last Jedi ranks, I think, solidly below the original trilogy, The Force Awakens, and Rogue One (though Rogue One is superfluous, but solidly above that wretched hive of scum and villainy, the Prequels.  I am happy that it breaks free from the derivativeness of The Force Awakens, but it simply isn’t as good a movie.  Nor does it add much to the world.  Looking back, one thing I really love about The Empire Strikes back is the sheer number of pulp SF elements thrown in, after the simpler story and world of Star Wars.  I said the third movie has a lot of heavy lifting to do, and in many ways that is a good thing.  For one, I really don’t know what to expect.  But there is a lot of risk too.

Advertisements

About H.P.

Blogs on books at Every Day Should Be Tuesday (speculative fiction) and Hillbilly Highways (country noir and nonfiction). https://everydayshouldbetuesday.wordpress.com/ https://hillbillyhighways.wordpress.com/
This entry was posted in Science Fiction, Sundry and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Spoiler Review of The Last Jedi (and Spoiler Comment Thread)

  1. Pingback: Non-Spoiler Review of The Last Jedi | Every Day Should Be Tuesday

  2. danielshumphreys says:

    Agree with the sentiment of Laura Dern’s character.

    My two other and primary issues were “I’m Leia Poppins, y’all!” and Luke milking the . . . whatever that was.

    Liked by 1 person

    • H.P. says:

      I thought the milk scene was mildly funny.

      As for Leia, well, given Carrie Fischer’s untimely death, I’m not sure they wouldn’t have been better off turning that into a death scene. There was nothing else for the remainder of the movie she strictly needed to be there for. We would have lost that last scene between Luke and Leia, but we could have had a scene just with Luke (the truth is, of the original three stars, only Hamill put in decent work on the new trilogy).

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Bookstooge says:

    Well, my already extremely low expectations just plowed nosefirst into the ground…

    Liked by 2 people

  4. Kyle says:

    Thanks for the review… interesting to see your thoughts… I didn’t care for Snoke at all… to me he just seemed another generic CGI bad guy like the Wonder Woman and Justice League villians…

    I liked Laura Dern’s character but your right on how she could just have avoided it all by explaining the plan to him… I suppose you could hand wave any number of excuses for that, but it the reasons aren’t shown in the movie they don’t count…

    re: you comments on first introduction to Rose… I am pretty sure it is Rose’s sister who was actually the one that climbed down the ladder and triggers the bomb release. The bomber gets destroyed… . Rose was like some plumber or something back on the main ship, she first shows up when she meets Finn. The sister on the bomber is who she is talking about, not the pilot…

    Liked by 2 people

    • H.P. says:

      It looks like you’re right about Paige and Rose. Which kind of takes away from Rose’s character.

      I thought the CGI for Snoke looked great. They’ve gotten so good as the motion capture stuff (the new Planet of the Apes trilogy is a pretty good display of the progression). My least favorite aspect of Snoke is that they never give us any kind of backstory in the movie, which makes him more generic.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. Off The TBR says:

    I’m still collecting my thoughts but I largely agree. Also, Phasma was a wasted useless character once again. Considering they just published a book about her I expected more. Then again Boba Fett didn’t do much either and he’s one of the most popular characters of the franchise. I’ll add more once I’ve let the movie settle a bit.

    Liked by 2 people

  6. Pingback: With The Last Jedi, Rian Johnson Took a Page from Brandon Sanderson | Every Day Should Be Tuesday

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s